Structured Water and Shilajit Ash The Health Coach

Structured Water and Shilajit: What Does Science Say?

November 17, 2026•6 min read

Introduction

You might have seen water advertised as 'structured', 'living', 'energised' or 'charged'. Sometimes the advice involves putting a bottle in the sun. Sometimes it involves a special machine. Then there are products such as shilajit, which people add to their morning water with a long list of promised benefits.

I understand the curiosity, because it's the same curiosity that sent me down this whole water rabbit hole in the first place. What actually makes water good? Can we improve it? Is there something we're missing?

But once somebody tells me a glass of water could improve my brain, fight disease and hydrate me better, my next question is: where's the evidence?

Quick answer: does structured water or shilajit hydrate you better?

There is interesting laboratory research into water close to particular surfaces, and there are preliminary studies into shilajit and fulvic acid. But those findings do not establish that drinking commercially sold structured water or adding shilajit to a glass improves everyday hydration or treats disease in people.

Can sunlight change the structure of water?

You might have heard that sunlight can “structure” water. I can see the appeal. A bottle, a sunny windowsill and, if you live in London, a bit of patience. But what did the researchers actually see?

In 2009, Chai, Yoo and Pollack studied water next to surfaces that attract it. Close to those surfaces, they noticed a small area that particles floating in the water stayed out of. They called it an exclusion zone. When they shone light on it, especially infrared light, that area grew.

That helps explain where some of the interest in “structured water” comes from. But nobody drank the water in that experiment. It leaves open whether any change would last once you drank it, let alone whether a bottle left in the sun would hydrate you better or improve your health.

Sunlight does have a known use in water treatment. Solar disinfection uses sunlight under specific conditions to reduce germs in water. Harmful chemicals and radioactive substances can still remain, so a spell on the windowsill is no way to know a glass of water is safe to drink.

What about shilajit and fulvic acid?

A slice of lime is easy enough to explain. Shilajit takes a bit more unpacking. It’s a substance used in Ayurvedic medicine, and one of the things it contains is fulvic acid. If you’ve seen claims about adding it to your morning water, it helps to know where those claims come from.

  • Memory and brain health
    A 2012 review looked at lab research on fulvic acid and tau, a protein that can form clumps in the brain in Alzheimer’s disease. The authors called for studies in people and raised concerns about contamination in unpurified shilajit.

  • Cancer and inflammation
    One study looked at cancer-related processes in cells grown in a lab. Another looked at how human immune cells send signals involved in inflammation. In both cases, the researchers studied cells in a dish.

  • Gut health and other effects
    One study looked at what happened when chickens were given fulvic acid. Another paper reviewed its possible effects on gut function, inflammation and the chemical reactions that can put cells under stress.

So would I add shilajit to my water for better hydration? These studies don’t give me enough of a reason yet. Also, knowing where your shilajit comes from is an important note too. They also don’t show that drinking it prevents Alzheimer’s disease or treats cancer in people. Which is the type of information that I want.

And that brings me back to the question I started with. What’s actually going in my glass? With a few mint leaves, I know what I’m adding and why I like it. With a supplement, I’d also want to know how pure it is, how much I’m taking and whether it’s suitable for me.

What's the difference between an interesting study and a useful health claim?

This is something I think about a lot in coaching. An exercise might produce an interesting result in a laboratory. That doesn't automatically mean every client should be doing it, or that the result will be the same in their body after twelve weeks.

Water research deserves the same treatment. Where did the experiment happen? Was it a laboratory dish, an animal study or a proper human trial? What was actually measured? And does it answer the question the product is asking you to believe?

A small experiment involving water near a surface is not the same as a trial showing that drinking a bottle of that water improves recovery or health.

Can sunlight disinfect drinking water?

Under specific conditions, solar disinfection can reduce certain harmful microorganisms. It is a genuine water-treatment method used where appropriate. But it has limitations, including the fact that sunlight doesn't remove chemical contamination from water.

Leaving a bottle on a London windowsill, crossing your fingers for sunshine and calling the contents 'alive' isn't a reliable water-quality test.

Is shilajit safe to add to water?

A product's quality matters. Shilajit is a naturally occurring mixture whose composition can vary, and unpurified or poorly controlled preparations can contain unwanted contaminants, including heavy metals. That deserves attention before discussing any potential benefit.

If I were considering it, I'd want evidence of quality testing for the specific product, a good reason to take it and evidence from human trials relevant to the claimed benefit. The 2012 review that brought shilajit into a lot of conversations raises interesting possibilities, but it does not demonstrate that taking it prevents Alzheimer's disease or improves hydration.

So what would I put in my water?

Most days, I'd keep it simple. Water from a supply I know is safe, perhaps with some lime, mint or cucumber if I fancy it.

I'm not against learning about new things. Quite the opposite. I spent years studying health and nutrition because the more I learned, the more questions I realised I had. I just don't want an interesting possibility to become a promise before the evidence is there.

If your aim is to feel better, train well and stay healthy, don't overlook the ordinary habits while searching for a magical glass of water.

You've reached the end of the water series. We started with what happens inside your body, followed water through the environment and the tap, looked at testing and treatment, and finished where we began: your glass. Now the job is to put what you've learned to use.


Your challenge

Next time you see a bold health claim about water or a supplement, ask what was actually tested and whether the results came from people. That one question goes a long way.

Until next time,

Ash – The Health Coach
Get Health. Heal Trying.

Sources & Further Reading

Chai, Yoo and Pollack (2009): Effect of Radiant Energy on Near-Surface Water
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19827846/

Carrasco-Gallardo et al. (2012): Shilajit Review
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3296184/

CDC: Household Water Treatment
https://www.cdc.gov/global-water-sanitation-hygiene/about/about-household-water-treatment.html

Ash - The Health Coach

Ash - The Health Coach

Health Coach in Hammersmith

Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog